Massive Root Beer Taste Test

Last year I had signed up to do a root beer taste test at Pop n Sweets, which included sampling 80 different root beers over about a 3 hour time period. They unfortunately don't do this anymore but it was super fun at the time.

The end result of taking "shots" of 80 different root beers is listed below. Also I found out what a "sugar high" was. 

During the taste test we wrote down our thoughts on each of the root beers gave them a score from 1 to 10 (listed below). After the taste test was all done, I decided to take all of the top two scores (which happened to be 7 and 8) and redo them for my own blind taste test. I was able to better compare them to each other and find a personal definitive root beer order.

Here is my blind taste test. Out of the 15 root beers with the top 2 scores, I could find 13 in stores. Apparently two of them weren't made or sold anymore in any stores I could find so they were left off the list. Below are the results.

 Here is my order of the top 13 root beers. I ended up breaking them into four distinct groups. The left group was Level A: Great!, middle was Level B: pretty good, and right was Level C: ok and the one to the far right was Level D: How the hell did you end up here?

Level A: Great!

1. Bulldog Root Beer
Thoughts: Slightly sugary taste but otherwise smooth.


















2. Empire Root Beer
Thoughts: Very similar to Bulldog. Hard to differentiate. Also a slightly sugary but smooth taste.
















3. Dang! Root Beer
Thoughts: Rich root beer taste that goes down smooth.
















4. Eli's Root Beer
Thoughts: Very similar to Dang!, couldn't really tell the difference. Same rich root beer taste that goes down smooth.

Level B: Very good

5. IBC Root Beer
Thoughts: Smooth, nice, soft flavor.

















6. Virgil's Special Edition Bavarian Nutmeg Root Beer
Thoughts: Almost a licorishy flavor but not quite. Good on ice cream.














7. Hippo Size Root Beer
Thoughts: Strong sugary taste but not too bad.
















8. Joe's Root Beer
Thoughts: Slight tinge of the vinegary taste that Triple XXX has, but pretty smooth.

Level C: OK and 

Level D: How the hell did you end up here?

 Level C: OK

9. Cicero Salted Caramel Root Beer
Thoughts: Very butterscotchy flavor but not too strong a taste. Pretty smooth.

















10. O-So Root Beer
Thoughts: Almost identical to Cicero, a not too strong butterscotchy flavor. Pretty candy smooth.


















11. Chicago Root Beer
Thoughts: A sbit sharp with the carbonation but when it's flat the taste is pretty smooth.
















12. Kutztown Birch Beer
Thoughts: Nearly identical to Chicago. Sharp with carbonation but smooth when flat.

Level D: How the hell did you end up here?

13. Triple XXX Root Beer
Thoughts: Watery and vinegary taste. Pretty gross.

Those are the thoughts on my personal taste test. Below is the results of all the root beers that I tried with my individual thoughts on them. When trying 80 different root beers it's hard to come up with very good taste descriptions but I tried.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Taste Test Drink Order	Name	Thoughts During Taste Test	Initial Score	Final Rank
74	Bulldog	Nice candy flavor	7	1
80	Empire	Nothing noted	7	2
33	Dang!	Smooth	7	3
72	Captain Eli's	Foamy and light	8	4
45	IBC	Pretty Good	7	5
25	Virgils Bavarian Nutmeg	Pretty Good	7	6
54	Hippo Size	Smooth	8	7
12	Joe's	Slight caramel taste	7	8
53	Cicero	Not bad	7	9
32	O-So Butterscotch	Toasted Marshmallow	7	10
11	Chicago	Smooth, nice	8	11
20	Kutz Town	Nice	7	12
27	Triple XXX	I like	8	13
4	Iron Horse	Smooth	7	NA
40	Big John Brewers	Nice	7	NA
10	Filbert's	Ok	6
21	Faygo	Kind of like a RB Float	6
22	Frostop	Smooth brown sugar	6
31	Foxon Park	Smooth sugary	6
67	Saranac	Nothing special, Ok	6
77	Bringham's Brew	Not too bad	6
79	Frostie	Not too bad, bit watery	6
1	Bedford's RB	Sugary, Okish	5
2	Speckher RB	Watery, not meh taste but smooth	5
7	Brownie Carmel Cream	Candy RB taste	5
14	Maine Root	Sugary light flavor	5
18	Red Arrow	Slight candy flavor	5
24	Frostie	Vanilla caramel	5
35	Ginseng Up	Slight sugar	5
38	Big Ben's	Light Flavor	5
48	Avery's	Smooth	5
52	The Pop Shoppe	Sugary	5
64	Anchor Ginger	Candyish	5
71	Route 66	Marshmallowy	5
76	Dang! Butterscotch	Candy - not too bad	5
78	Rocky Mt.	Flavored water	5
5	Dr. Brown	Watery, but better than 2	4
9	Barrel Brothers	Very fizzy. Don't taste much	4
13	Dog n Suds	Slight sugary taste	4
17	Crater Lake	Ok. A little sugary	4
19	Sparky's	Lingering candy flavor	4
34	Old Red Eye	Candy. Cheap	4
43	Polar	Eh	4
47	Caruso's	RB Candy	4
51	American	Brown Sugar water	4
58	Zuber Fizz	Nothing special	4
62	Dad's	Light candy	4
66	Thomas Kemper	Marshmallow aftertaste	4
69	Reading Draft	Weird flavor	4
8	Tower	Meh	3
26	Bawls	Meh sourish tatse	3
37	Hosmer	RB Candy	3
42	Boylan	Too Sugary	3
44	Ramlin	Fake	3
49	Death Valley	Too Sugary	3
55	Sioux City	Brown sugar	3
57	Fireman's Brew	Light flavor	3
60	AJ Stephans Butterscotch	Caramel flavoring	3
61	WBC	Meh	3
63	Capone	Not much flavor	3
68	Abita	Sugary candy	3
3	So-da RB	Butterscotchy	2
15	Waialua	Weird taste	2
28	Salted Caramel	Licorishy burnt brown sugar	2
30	Johnny Ryan	Watery sugar	2
41	River City	Fake Flavoring	2
56	Squamscot	Watery sugar, no flavor	2
65	Virgils	Caramel	2
70	Crooked Oak	Vinegary water	2
73	Bundaberg	Meh	2
6	Gale's	Weird Taste	1
16	Stewarts	Strong brown sugar aftertaste	1
23	Old Brooklyn	Too much candy taste	1
36	New York Seltzer	Clear. Not good.	1
50	Swamp Pop File	Vinegary	1
59	Jackson Hole Buckin	Licorice	1
29	Oogave	Oh god no	0
39	Fest Pecan	Burnt	0
75	Tommy Knockers	Strong cloves or something	0
46	Fenteman's Dandelion & Burdock	Awful	-1

The Kitchen Remodel - From Start to Finish

We had moved into this house in 2008, and since then we have not really liked the kitchen. Our purpose was always to remodel it but we were never sure when or what exactly we wanted to do. Then slowly we started getting all the pieces in order. We replaced all of the windows in the house first, then the sliding back and side doors since those ran into the floor. Finally we were ready to begin.

Pre-Pictures

Below are some images from right after we moved into the house. We painted a little and changed the furniture around a bit but otherwise it didn't change much.

Kitchen facing the sliding door

Designing the Kitchen

When we finally decided to go ahead with the kitchen, Veronica (the wife) sketched out some ideas of what we should do. This included changing the wall with the fridge to be a pass through kitchen island and moving the fridge elsewhere.

Once we had determined roughly what we wanted, we moved on the Ikea and spent several hours and days working with their design software. Getting all the dimensions perfect and adding in cabinets and appliances where we wanted them. We decided that we were going to get rid of everything except the fridge. Below are the Ikea printouts of the kitchen layout.

The great thing about the Ikea software is that it can produce a 3D rotatable image of the kitchen. Here is what our kitchen was estimated to look like.

Destruction

 On September 2nd, 2015 we went and purchased the kitchen at Ikea. They asked if we wanted to take all 175 packages home with us right then. "Ummmm, what?". Didn't know that was an option. We ended up just having them delivered along with having to grab a few other packages from elsewhere across the city. That and countless trips back to Ikea to add and exchange things made a lot of trips.

September 4th, 2015

Ready for destruction. You can see the wife had already removed the old floor.

Starting with removing the wall where the fridge was/is located.

We assumed and had confirmation that there was significant water damage below the sink and dishwasher. I had already thought we would have to replace the subfloor, this just confirmed it.

September 6th, 2015

The wall is completely gone now. Along with all of the upper cabinets. The cabinets has a small false wall above them that we wanted to remove as well.

September 7th, 2015

Delivery Day!!!!!!

The day we are gifted with tons and tons of boxes. I think these boxes got moved around more than anything else in the house. We had to keep moving them out of the way, eventually putting most of them upstairs.

September 10th, 2015

The frame for the small wall is starting to go in.

 September 11th, 2015

Removed the small wall that jutted out above the cabinets along with the paneling that was on the wall behind the cabinets.

September 16th

We had gotten far enough by this point to call in the electrician we needed. I Knew exactly what we needed done, but it was a lot of work. Once they arrived we were able to get everything on the above image (which I sent them) done.

 September 19th, 2015

Cabinets were starting to be put together along with continued demo in the kitchen.

September 27th, 2015

Adding in the overhanging cabinets over the island. They were initially pushed up against the ceiling. The fit between the walls was WAY too tight though and ended up with me having to sand down one of the walls heavily, and still ended up having to jam the cabinets up. Then we did have to eventually take them down to add in a 2x4 spacer, but luckily they slid right back up without much of an issue.

The electrical has been completed by this point.

October 6th, 2015

Added in drywall and starting to paint the kitchen walls and ceiling. We have not yet fully removed all of the old kitchen cabinets yet because we wanted to reduce the amount of time we didn't have running water in the kitchen.

October 11th, 2015

The walls are done. Sink is the only old cabinet remaining.

 October 15th, 2015

The sink was finally removed along with a chunk of the floor to replace. This meant having to remove all pipes and drains to the sink and dishwasher.

 October 17th, 2015

New floor installed.

 October 20th, 2015

New floor finished off and upper cabinets added.

 October 21st, 2015

Lower cabinets placed into position.

 October 24th, 2015

Larger wall cabinets added and lower cabinets secured. 

 October 26th, 2015

By this point we were ready for the countertop. However, we didn't realize that the lower  paneling needed to be attached to the lower cabinets in order to measure for the countertop. To attach the paneling, we needed the floor installed. And so began the marathon of installing the floor. And of course the walls aren't straight so we had to start on the far side of the dining room. 

 October 27th, 2015

Most of the floor has been finished in just over a day. The most important parts are around the paneling, which are done.

View into the main kitchen area, which is a mess at this point since that is where everything went when the floor was put in.

October 29th, 2015

Appliances are being installed slowly. First in is the stacked microwave and oven.

 November 5th, 2015

Paneling is finalized and most of the floor is finished.

 November 6th, 2015

Getting ready for the countertop to be installed. Cabinets are starting to be used and doors and drawers being added.

Dishwasher installed and water pipes are being added. The drain was already replaced by the time the cabinets were installed.

For some reason the cooktop did not fit into the cabinet space which it was supposed to fit. So before the countertop was installed I needed to cut in grooves on the sides so that the cooktop slid in nicely once everything was said and done.

Still the same day after all of the countertops have been added and the cooktop installed.

November 12th, 2015

Spent a long weekend in the crawl space getting the faucet hooked up after about a month of having no running water in the kitchen. Dishes were cleaned in the upstairs bathroom.

 November 14th, 2015

So nice and tidy under the sink now. Everything is installed and the dishwasher is now hooked up.

 November 20th, 2015

Moving towards finalizing major construction and getting the walls ready for painting.

Added the doors to the cabinets.

December 14th, 2015

We ran into a problem with the ceiling. We had a popcorn ceiling in the dining room, a stucco ceiling in the kitchen, and a tiled ceiling in the front entryway, all of which were now flowing into one another. So the wife found plans to add paneling and whitewash the ceiling. This project alone took about a month to do but it came out looking very very good.

 January 9th, 2016

Finally finished the ceiling panels.

January 23rd, 2016

Whitewashed the ceiling.

 February 1st, 2016

Added a new fan and lights.

Also was able to add in most of the tiling along the kitchen wall. There was a contention over this type of tile and a more "rocky" tile but I lost.

February 3rd, 2016

Added tile to the island walls to tie it into the kitchen as well.

 April 4th, 2016

Needed to remove the doors to redo the walls around the front entryway. There was paneling along much of the doorway, however we removed it above the door and to do the mudding of the walls, the doors needed to be taken down.

Inside view.

 May 12th, 2015

By this point, we had finished all of the major projects except building the bookshelf/bench that was going around the dining room window. This is the window picture I took to Ikea to have them help me get the required materials.

 May 14th, 2016

Most of the kitchen is in final shape, with the walls all painted to what we wanted.

May 16th, 2016

Started construction on the wall unit. 

 May 27th, 2016

Installing the cabinets.

 May 28th, 2016

May 30th, 2016

Working on the bench seat.

 June 1st, 2016

June 5th, 2016

Mostly finished on the bottom.

June 18th, 2016

The bottom portion of the wall unit is completed including cabinet tops for the end cabinets.

 June 22nd, 2016

Starting to build the top part of the cabinets.

 July 16th, 2016

Wall unit is complete.

Job Complete!!!!!!

 November 17th, 2016

During the completing phase, we ran into several small problems that took a while to resolve. The floor was losing stain rather easily so I added more stain and sealed the floor. Also some of the undercabinet lights were overheating in the attic, so I had to rewire them so they came down into the kitchen, like the other lights.

Since the main entryway ran into the stairwell, this was added to the to-do part of the project. That added a bit of time to get everything complete.

So, in all, it took over 15 months to complete, but the major part of the project was done before Thanksgiving of 2015. We had running water in the kitchen and all appliances were hooked up. The rest of the project dragged out for quite a long time because we didn't have as much time to devote to it as we did earlier in the project. But by the time it was done, over 1/3rd of the house was completely demoed and redone.